Accommodating IOLs may very well transform the practice of cataract and refractive lens surgery. This is because accommodative IOLs can potentially provide unaided near visual acuity without the optical aberrations and image degradation that may accompany multifocal IOL implantation. Not only will this enhance cataract surgery results, but it will also enable refractive surgeons to offer their patients a procedure that is unhindered by the restrictions of corneal refractive surgery and presbyopia. Accommodating lenses can currently be classified into 3 categories: (1) single-optic, (2) dual-optic, (3) and deformable optic IOLs. This article will explore the available accommodative technologies under these 3 headings including any limitations concerning lens excursion and accommodative amplitude and examine the potential impact of these IOLs on cataract and refractive surgeons and patients.
Single-Optic IOLs
The Morcher BioComFold Type 43E, HumanOptics 1 CU, Lenstec TetraFlex, and eyeonics crystalens are examples of single-optic IOLs. Single-optic, accommodating IOLs function by changing their position in the capsular bag during accommodative effort with a resulting increase in the effective power but not the inherent power of the lens. The limitations of these IOLs stem from their inability to move significantly enough to generate large amplitudes of accommodative power that would yield consistently acceptable near visual acuities.
The Morcher BioComfold 43E is a single-optic/ring haptic lens. During accommodative effort, the ring haptics are brought together resulting in a forward axial movement of the optic with a resultant increase in the functional power of the lens. A recent study using pilocarpine 2% to simulate accommodation and partial coherence interferometry to measure the changes in anterior chamber depth (and, thus, forward movement of the IOL) revealed no more than 0.50 diopters (D) of accommodative amplitude in most cases (J Cataract Refract Surg. 2003;29:669-676). The Morcher BioComfold 43E is not approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
The HumanOptics 1CU is a hydrophilic, acrylic, foldable, single-piece lens with a biconvex square-edge optic and 4 modified flexible haptics that allow for forward movement of the optic during accommodative effort (Figure 1). In a similar study as that performed with the Morcher BioComfold IOL, median anterior movement of the HumanOptics 1CU after pilocarpine 2% instillation was calculated to result in a refractive change of no more than 0.5 D in most patients (Ophthalmology. 2004;111:1515-1521). Although other studies have demonstrated much higher degrees of accommodative amplitudes, unfavorable results among European ophthalmologists who have utilized this lens will in all likelihood impair its success in the general market. The HumanOptics 1CU is also not FDA approved.